Bug no save control config Nes Ratrobat 5.3.0

Hi I have problems saving the control settings, when exiting the emulator it returns with the default settings.

in previous versions it works fine for me

Hello
Which settings do you try to change?
Have you seen that ?

https://retrobat.forumgaming.fr/t135-faq-retrobat-wip#2754

Hi thanks for answer im change this configuration no have problem in version 5.1.0 and 5.2.0


check in emulator save config try in retrobat 5.3.0 and the config no save before restar game

Hello,

Retrobat automatically regenerates the "core input remap", so you must save as folder or game remap if you save a manual mapping.
It was already like that in 5.2.

tartifless wrote:Hello,

Retrobat automatically regenerates the "core input remap", so you must save as folder or game remap if you save a manual mapping.
It was already like that in 5.2.

Thanks for using save as folder this affect all emulator in retroarch in 5.3.0 for exaple im change A and B posittion in controller ps5 B=square A=X Bturbo=Triangle ATurbo=Circle, this change automatic my buttons in snes emulator and now B is A and A is B the orginal snes button
maybe only option is change for games but I will have to change the button configuration for each new game, which could only be done by emulator

I forgot to say that the images are from version 5.2.0 I had to go back to the previous version to see if it was not a configuration problem and I tried 5.3.0 again and the problem continued so I went back to version 5.2.0

I don't understand the problem, can you explain better ?

tartifless wrote:I don't understand the problem, can you explain better ?

ok well my english is not good
What happens in version 5.3.0 does not allow saving the configuration with the disabled option to autoconfigure controls when making the change and saving in the core reassignment option when exiting the game and re-entering the configuration returns to default and When you want to see the option where it is saved, it is as if you had not saved anything, this does not happen to me in previous versions
As I put in the images, I had to go back to version 5.2.0, as I put in the images, this is how it is saved in the Nes games, only configuring 1 game, all of them are left with the configuration that I assigned.

Hello,

Yes this is normal, not a bug, Retrobat automatically generates the core input mapping in order to be able to set the controller type that is selected in RetroBat to the core.
This is not bug, if we change that it is not possible anymore to choose between the different controller types the core offers (for example snes cores offer controller, gun, mouse, etc.).

Retroarch only recognizes what is written in a remap file.

So the "core remap" cannot be used to save your own mapping.

You will notice in version 5.2 that if you change controller type in a core (for example horizontal wiimote or gun), it will not work.

But what is the actual problem you are trying to solve ?

tartifless wrote:Hello,

Yes this is normal, not a bug, Retrobat automatically generates the core input mapping in order to be able to set the controller type that is selected in RetroBat to the core.
This is not bug, if we change that it is not possible anymore to choose between the different controller types the core offers (for example snes cores offer controller, gun, mouse, etc.).

Retroarch only recognizes what is written in a remap file.

So the "core remap" cannot be used to save your own mapping.

You will notice in version 5.2 that if you change controller type in a core (for example horizontal wiimote or gun), it will not work.

But what is the actual problem you are trying to solve ?

Thanks, Well the problem when I had my version 5.2.0 I had saved my button configuration in the Nes after updating the button configuration it returns to the default and now it does not save the button changes
that is, in 5.2.0 if I save the configuration,
and in 5.3.0 it no longer saves, that was the problem, I don't know if it was a bug or they changed the configuration so that it does not allow saving

Here in the image I put the option of deactivating the auto-configuration of controls, which in 5.1.0 and 5.2.0 does allow me to save the changes of the control buttons when I exit and enter the game, the configuration that I left is maintained, but in 5.3 .0 With this option being activated or deactivated, now the saving of buttons does not work anymore, it returns to the original configuration every time I exit the game and enter it again


In this image it shows that I save the kernel control configuration and it shows that I save in FCEUmm.rpm when exiting and re-entering in 5.1.0 and 5.2.0 those options are maintained but in 5.3.0 when doing the same settings saving when exiting and re-entering the game is as if nothing were saved, the option to save the core is not selected, nor does it appear in which core it is, that is, FCEUmm.rpm



What I would need to try would be to configure it by emulator, that no longer moved it since the option to autoconfigure the command worked fine for me, if it is not a bug then that option no longer works as before  


As a final summary I would say control autoconfiguration option works in 5.1.0 and 5.2.0 they work
in 5.3.0 that option no longer works for me  


I leave here more images of how I make the change





Play Station 5 Controller (decault control is X=B Circle=A Square=Turbo B Triangle=Turbo A)








I don't know if I solved the question, it's that I'm also using the google translator

Hello,

You need to save for the directory "nes", not for the core, or save for the game.

Save for the core is erased by Retrobat and regenerated by Retrobat to solve other issues.

tartifless wrote:Hello,

You need to save for the directory "nes", not for the core, or save for the game.

Save for the core is erased by Retrobat and regenerated by Retrobat to solve other issues.

Hi good morning If you mean this option, I used it in 5.3.0



If this option works, it saves my configuration, but the problem of saving in that option affects all retroarch configuration.
For example, change the buttons in the nes Contra game, I save in the option that you told me, I go out and play the SNES Contra 3 in that emulator, I leave the default controls of the super nintendo but when I play I notice that the buttons are changed, in the game Originally you jump with B and activate bomb with A, but now they are backwards B is Bomb and A is jump, which here does not modify the button configuration only on Nes so it affected me to save in that option on Nes and also It affected the configuration of SNES, I don't know if I explained it well, but if you have any questions, tell me thanks (remember this only happens to me in 5.3.0 the button saving thing, in 5.2.0 I don't have that problem I tried 2 times with new installations and only in 5.3.0 the option to save auto configure controls disabled)

We know it does not happen in 5.2.0, it was introduced as a fix in 5.2.1

tartifless wrote:We know it does not happen in 5.2.0, it was introduced as a fix in 5.2.1

oki Well I just have to try in the advanced system configuration options



I will reinstall 5.3.0 and try that option

Hello,

This will not change the behaviour, it is by design

Well, I give up, I can't save the configuration, now the hotkeys I modify my buttons, but when I save the configuration, it goes back to the default. Is there an option so that I can modify these buttons and save it in 5.3.0.
I think I'll stay at 5.2.0

Well I'll keep moving more options but I don't see more than in versions 5.1.0 and 5.2.0 which were those options that if I saved the configuration